Core Editorial Responsibilities
Editors provide initial assessments, select qualified reviewers, and synthesize feedback into clear decisions. Editorial judgments must remain unbiased and based solely on scientific merit.
Editors should verify ethical approvals, data transparency statements, and conflict disclosures before acceptance to protect the integrity of the record.
When reviewer opinions conflict, editors should provide balanced decisions that reflect evidence strength and study limitations.
Editors should document rationale for decisions to ensure transparency and consistency.
If availability or conflicts arise, notify the editorial office promptly so assignments can be reassigned without delays.
Reviewer Selection
Invite reviewers with relevant skeletal expertise and no conflicts of interest.
Decision Letters
Provide clear guidance, required revisions, and respectful communication.
